Something to be wary of when you’re domain shopping for that perfect .com: bots are watching.
I’m not sure what combination triggers it, but when I was done brainstorming for an app name, I checked Twitter to see if the handle was taken, then registered the domain name. It was quite late and I didn’t want to start fiddling around with email aliases to get the Twitter account, so I decided to leave it since the application is only in early planning and layout stages.
A couple of days later, I decided to grab the account to start playing around with the Twitter API – couldn’t believe it when I discovered the account had been nabbed. No updates, no avatar – just a squatter. It seems obvious in retrospect that someone would be scraping domain registrations and comparing against Twitter handles (there was nothing but the .com taken and I’d never mentioned it anywhere), but it is immensely frustrating. The app is a Twitter-based tool, so having a .com and matching account name is essential.
What’s even more frustrating is that this seems to fall within Twitter’s acceptable usage policy. They have a section on namesquatting, but it states:
“Please note that if an account has had no updates, no profile image, and there is no intent to mislead, it typically means there’s no name-squatting or impersonation.”
You’d be hard-pressed to claim that there is an “intent to mislead” when you’re starting to build something – after all, the fact that you’re only starting to build it means there’s not much to mislead. So I’m back to the drawing board on figuring out a name while I put the app together.
The lesson here, a rather obvious one I suppose, is that Twitter handles are as valuable as the domain for certain classes of applications. If you’re building something that will interface with Twitter, you have to get the Twitter handle at the same time as the domain, or it’ll be swept out from under you.
Edit:
As per Andrew’s comment below, I’ve submitted an impersonation report – hopefully something will come of it.
Update:
Well, it looks like this might be going places, the account in question is now showing as “suspended” – no word from support yet (it’s a weekend, I wasn’t expecting anything until at least Monday) but it’s encouraging!
Update 2011-08-29:
So, received some communication from Twitter today; they will not release the account name to me. This is disappointing, but I will move on.
17 Comments
Don’t give up! I had the same exact thing happen to me. I contacted Twitter support and the handle was passed over to me in less than 48 hours.
Submit an impersonation report here: https://support.twitter.com/forms/impersonation
And explain the exact situation. You bought the domain, and someone is now squatting the handle. I believe the account must be inactive for a month before that will hand it over to you. (Not 100% sure on that)
Again, don’t give up! Twitter is aware of the squatters problem and I am sure they will be able to help you just like they did us.
Thanks Andrew, that’s heartening to hear!
As I haven’t done anything quite so forward as to register a company for this side-project I figured I’d be ignored.
Glad things worked out for you, I’ll give it a shot!
Hey,
I did face the exact issue while i registered a domain with GoDaddy ( March 10, 2010). Instantly after i registered the domain, the (Twitter check function ), told me that the handle was registered.
I was shocked, and after going through the documentation I went for an alternative
handle. I thought contacting Twitter may resolve the issue. Twitter in reply said:
If you’re looking to acquire an inactive username for personal use, please check back in a few months. We’re currently unable to accommodate individual requests for inactive usernames. We may release all inactive usernames in the future, but have not yet set a date for doing so.
Twitter is only transferring usernames under our trademark policy (http://support.twitter.com/articles/18367). If you are writing on behalf of a trademarked brand, you can file that new ticket for our policy team to review. You can file a new ticket here: http://support.twitter.com/forms/trademark
And the account is still Dormant, with no avatar, no tweets, no followers.
Thanks for the solution, ill give it a try again
I have tweet.co.in that i’m willing to lend if you have an interesting app around it .
Hi, I faced the same issues however Twitter support team helped me get all thr handles we were looking for and were taken up by inactive Twitter guys.
We faced a similar problem – and your case would indicate, that the name leaked out at the domain registrar …
http://blog.internet-briefing.ch/2011/06/24/how-save-are-the-new-facebook-messages/comment-page-1/
Unfortunately, we only got a standard answer from Twitter and did NOT get the handle, so had to go for another name http://sort.li – let me know, if you succeed, then we may try it again. The original name may be a better choice …
I almost wish Twitter charged a nominal fee for accounts. Do you think that owning the domain name should be justification enough for turning over unused Twitter handles?
@Arkay: thanks, but I’m hoping to go for something a little more specific
@Markus: Will do, thanks for the heads up!
@John: I don’t think it makes sense unilaterally, but in cases where it is clearly an attempted roadblock (or more likely, speculating on an opportunity for future extortion) then it makes sense to me that there would be some sort of help available.
@Ross Thanks for this post and @Andrew Guenther for the solution, I finally got the Twitter handle Back.
Hi Shakir, glad you managed to find a resolution to your problem!
I received a response from Twitter today and unfortunately, as I suspected, the namesquatting policy does not apply to my situation as far as Twitter are concerned.
Onwards and upwards.
@Ross, i understand your concern. The handle i requested was released on terms of “Inactivity”, as the username was still inactive after 12 months. I dont think you can wait to reclaim the handle after few months(depends, if your beta launch is scheduled later) .
Can this scraping be reported to Twitter to act in the best intentions to avoid squatting ?
I feel that Domain registrars may have some contribution in it.
Hey Ross,
Just out of interest who did you register the domain name with ?
Hi Keith,
Registered with Blacknight.
I had a similar issue before, but I only checked if a domain was free, which it was, went to registered it a day or two later and it was registered the day after I checked !
I knew you can get ‘recently registered’ lists from some registrars, but Blacknight, have you been on to them ?
http://www.dailychanges.com/dreamhost.com/
Ive registered quite a number of twitter and facebook handles for my clients on the back of domain registrations and I havent as yet come across this.
I also had the same but after I checked it a day or two it was already registered. Thanks @Andrew Guenther for the solution, really helps.
Sad to hear you didn’t get the handle, but yeah, namesquatters are here to stay sadly. Grab them while you can.
7 Trackbacks
[…] Andrew Guenther explained to Ross Duggan, by contacting Twitter support and submitting this information on an impersonation […]
[…] Bots are crawling new domain registrations and namesquatting Twitter handles | Ross Duggan […]
[…] what Ross Duggan thinks happened to him. He finally found the perfect unregistered domain name for his new project. He checked on Twitter […]
[…] dat is wat Ross Duggan lijkt te zijn overkomen zoals hij beschrijft in zijn blog. Ross had een idee voor een app die samen zou moeten werken met Twitter. Na enige, stille, […]
[…] Twitter user has discovered that someone is registering Twitter accounts based on new domain registrations. This could be a coincidence, but either way the model breaks down: it’s hard to contact the […]
[…] I read a post linked from HackerNews: Bots are crawling new domain registrations and namesquatting Twitter handles. On that post there was a comment from Andrew Guenther: “Don’t give up! I had the same […]
[…] Bots are crawling new domains registrations and namesquatting twitter handles – http://rossduggan.ie/blog/technology/bots-are-crawling-new-domain-registratio… […]